Shiner–Davison–Landsberg complexity revisited
نویسنده
چکیده
Shiner, Davison and Landsberg have recently proposed a measure of complexity that has become the subject of an intense debate. We show that using the framework of the thermodynamic formalism, the properties and shortcomings of this measure—over-universality and a trivial implementation of the temperature dependence—can be interpreted and elucidated in a coherent way. Moreover, we show how the SDL approach can be refined to nullify these critiques. Results of the logistic parabola family demonstrate the improved behaviour of the modified SDL measure of complexity. For the tent map family, an interesting linear dependence of the modified measure as a function of the asymmetry is observed.
منابع مشابه
Comment on the Shiner–Davison–Landsberg Measure
The complexity measure from Shiner et al. [Physical Review E 59, 1999, 1459–1464] (henceforth abbreviated as SDL-measure) has recently been the subject of a fierce debate. We discuss the properties and shortcomings of this measure, from the point of view of our recently constructed fundamental, statistical mechanics-based measures of complexity Cs (γ, β) [Stoop et al., J. Stat. Phys. 114, 2004,...
متن کاملComparison of SDL and LMC measures of complexity: Atoms as a testbed
The simple measure of complexity Γα,β of Shiner, Davison and Landsberg (SDL) and the statistical one C, according to López-Ruiz, Mancini, and Calbet (LMC) are compared in atoms as functions of the atomic number Z. Shell effects i.e. local minima at the closed shells atoms are observed as well as similar qualitative trends of Γα,β(Z) and C(Z). It is conjectured that the above conclusion does not...
متن کاملComment I on "Simple measure for complexity"
We critique the measure of complexity introduced by Shiner, Davison, and Landsberg [Phys. Rev. E 59, 1459 (1999)]. In particular, we point out that it is over universal, in the sense that it has the same dependence on disorder for structurally distinct systems. We then give counterexamples to the claim that complexity is synonymous with being out of equilibrium: equilibrium systems can be struc...
متن کاملua nt - p h / 06 05 08 2 v 2 16 O ct 2 00 6 Comparison of SDL and LMC measures of complexity : Atoms as a testbed
The simple measure of complexity Γα,β of Shiner, Davison and Landsberg (SDL) and the statistical one C, according to López-Ruiz, Mancini and Calbet (LMC), are compared in atoms as functions of the atomic number Z. Shell effects i.e. local minima at the closed shells atoms are observed, as well as certain qualitative trends of Γα,β(Z) and C(Z). If we impose the condition that Γ and C behave simi...
متن کاملDynamic Complexity Measures: definition and calculation
This work is a generalization of the López-Ruiz, Mancini and Calbet (LMC); and Shiner, 1 Davison and Landsberg (SDL) complexity measures, considering that the state of a system or process 2 is represented by a dynamical variable during a certain time interval. As the two complexity 3 measures are based on the calculation of informational entropy, an equivalent information source 4 is defined an...
متن کامل